SUMMARY WRITTEN BY-SURYA PRAKASH PATTANAYAK
This novel
was written by Robert Harris. It has won the Walter Scott Prize and the
American Library in Paris Book Award in 2014. And a French feature film is
being made on the same storyline and having the same title by director Roman
Polanski and produced by Alain Goldman.
Georges
Picquart is the narrator of Harris’s fiction, which, as he writes in his note,
“aims to use the techniques of a novel to retell the true story of the Dreyfus
affair, perhaps the greatest political scandal and miscarriage of justice in
history”.
The
Franco-Prussian conflict had resulted in mortification for France; Paris fell
in 1871, and the territories of Alsace and Lorraine were captured by Germany. Over
the following decades, many French officials and elites were convicted of
spying and espionage for the enemies, especially Germans. Then, in 1894, came
the news of the arrest of Alfred Dreyfus, a captain in the French artillery
division. Dreyfus was Jewish by religion; his ancestors ware from Alsace. He
was accused of passing secret information to the Germans. He was convicted,
“degraded” – stripped of his rank and position, his rank sword was broken in
two before the army’s massed ranks – and sent to solitary confinement on
Devil’s Island. In the meantime, Georges Picquart was positioned at the
topnotch position of the French military intelligence service at a secret
location.
Initially,
Picquart had hatred and revengeful opinions regarding Dreyfus. Picquart doesn’t
approve of the ritual ‘degradation’ of the ceremony, but at this early point,
he is utterly certain of Dreyfus’s guilt. But later on, this man becomes the
mastermind in the investigation of Dreyfus’s case and which will lead to the
real culprit and reinstatement of Dreyfus.
As the story
proceeds Picquart working environment was full of chaos and confusion and
equally complicated. But his expert instinct for management solves all the
problems. A minor investigation by Piquart of his predecessor officer
Esterhazy, in the backwater of Rouen, shows links with German embassy
diplomats. On further inquiry, he ends up with dept ridden finances of
Esterhazy. His suspicion confirms as he gets clues regarding the regular timed
drop of drafts and its contents. Now slowly Piquart who used to be an
intelligence officer completely turned into an undercover agent. He starts
vigilance and procedure for picking pieces of evidence and other tactics to
reach the snooping base of the German base.
As time goes by
Piquart goes by new incites by Dreyfus his investigation added up heavenly
censored, undelivered letters Dreyfus to his wife. Though his initial
skepticism towards Dreyfus and prisoner’s denial he slowly develops a soft
corner for the prisoner.
After sometime
Piquart gets some irrefutable and undeniable evidence against Esterhazy the
real spy and other pieces of evidence that prove Dreyfus's false conviction. He
presents all these documents to his superiors but he gets a stark refusal for
case reopening. He received a severe rebuke from his seniors and forced to drop
the case. Meanwhile, several newspapers and journals started mass campaigns in
support of Dreyfus and get him released.
Commendable
clever detective work is done by Picquart in subsequent chapters which include
photographs of Esterhazy entering the German embassy and leaving empty hand,
spying coup, secret apartment spyhole and listening tube surveillance. All
these were done by Picquart, to arrange undeniable evidence against reluctant Esterhazy
and get him behind the bars. He was successful in his endeavor and arranged him
with two important pieces of documents. The first one is secret dossier
evidence sent to the judge during court-martial proceedings kept by his
predecessor and the second one is application Esterhazy to the ministry, having
identical handwriting to that of the list passed to Germans. That supposed to
be written by Dreyfus. Suddenly Picquart feels insinuated into whole shabby
business, as he the man who passed the dossier for the trial.
Here comes
the first flashback in the story from the Dreyfus. Picquart used to be
Dreyfus's professor at the military academy and it was his job before he moved
into army intelligence ministry. He used to be a mentor inside the ministry for
ex-students doing the internship. A small incident has been described. Dreyfus
being unpopular upper class tried to hike his marks. But Piquart stood firm on
his stand and Dreyfus got the lowest in all discipline. Another flashback
erupts ministry informs that there is a spy among them it took no time to name
Dreyfus as the main suspect all due to his inquisitive nature and easy access
to all the departments. Nobody liked him overall, he was a Jew. All had serious
doubts about his loyalty towards his country. A proper trap was led for Dreyfus
with little publicity and Piquart finds himself involved. Though he knew
nothing behind scenes work, he was the one who ushered Dreyfus to the trap.
Also, he was the one who handed over the dossier to the jury. Which ultimately
led to the fatal conviction of Dreyfus.
Just like
every spy and mystery thriller story author incorporates minute detail to
increase the reader's excitement and association with the novel. Like Piquart
used a little key to access the ministry office to get more relevant findings
behind his seniors’ attention. But his troubles and official pressure hiked day
by day due to unwelcome publicity in high profile newspapers about the case.
His seniors informed him that they are not interested in Dreyfus's innocence.
When they realized that he was carrying out his investigation in forced and
ruthless attitude they forced him to stop. First of all, his key stopped
working, he had to use a lock-picking tool to case material. When he put all
these testimonials together, he discovered that all seniors including Mercier
perfectly knew that ‘D’ mention in an enemy keyword does not refer Dreyfus but
to another spy Dubois. Now the whole picture was clear Piquart that Dreyfus is
innocent and prosecutors knew it perfectly.
Multiple
handwriting experts were called to testify the Dreyfus handwriting until one of
them agreed willingly. Also, Piquart now found a coded message that Germans
never knew Dreyfus, but he returned it to the coder to get a proper translation
fitting prosecutor’s stand. On multiple occasions, Piquart was constantly
reminded to withdraw from his investigations, but he continued his endeavor.
Day by day
Dreyfus was life in prison was turned into hell. Also, seniors’ military
officials wanted him dead as it would save them from defamation. Leg irons were
fitted to him to cut his ankles leading to life-threating infections.
As time
passed on ministry and Piquart seniors tried multiple conspiracies and
fabrications to avoid the unrevealing of truth. Piquart Paris tour, seven-month
exile, and the act of implication into treason were part of their modus
operandi. Piquart was strongly determined and faced every adversary with great
strength. He has now become a whistleblower. He gets permission for a week's
leave to Paris; he was sticking to the official protocol as far as he could. At
Paris, he met with old friend Lebloys, who is a lawyer he handed over his
16-paragraph summary of his investigation. Lebloys forwards them to vice
president of France and Piquart returns them.
As expected,
even after 4 months nothing substantial happened from government authorities.
But public pressure and Dreyfus story pilling on day by day. Suddenly Piquart
starts seeing his name associated with the case in the newspaper’s headline. He
received a summon from Paris. Later on, he realized that summon was a trap and
he faced investigation at Paris under General Pellieux. Picquart insinuated
that the army will adopt anything, including the releasing of a spy, to ratify
the verdict stated against Dreyfus. Unfortunately, Piquart was sent to prison.
Picquart's lawyer discovers a great loop in the army’s statement. Even though
successful attempts of Picquart’s lawyer, the court supported the army’s
opinion. The Piquart was removed from the army.
Meanwhile,
advertising and propaganda about the state of Dreyfus at Devil’s Island kept
the case in the public eye afresh. A prominent anti-Dreyfus speech in
parliament backfired. The jury decides to bring back Dreyfus for the re-run of
his court-martial in public. Now Picquart is free to assist with the
investigation, and the army officials are on the back foot. Boisdeffre, one was
the first to resign, and Henry was apprehended as he has done a serious
forgery. But he silted his throat in prison cell.
The
court-martial took place at Rennes, and it became a popular press event.
Dreyfus senescence horribly in his imprisonment. But evidence that has been
collected for years is now admissible, and it’s easy for the army to prove that
Dreyfus has no case against him to answer.
But on
Saturday court, Mercier made a dramatic act. He has politically ambitious and
was willing to lie to serve his purpose. He did a great show of pain and
outrage felt by a wronged man, he pretended that any harm to the army would be
an advantage to Germany. He further adds that victory for Dreyfus would be a
defeat. The court was adjourned till Monday. Meanwhile, the lawyer was shot and
wounded badly.
At that
moment Mercier was off the clutches of law Dreyfus was still guilty as per
major verdict. But public opinion and support for Dreyfus rose day by day and
demand for political pardon was proliferated. The campaign in support of
Dreyfus and Picquart was at its peak. All newspapers, journals, and magazines devoted
their headlines for this cause. All these incident’s briefing reached the
senate and government adhered to public demand.
Down the
line, as the years passed, everything was brought back to normalcy. Mercier
later returned to the army as Major. Dreyfus was reinstated with all honor and
reputation. Piquart was positioned at a much higher rank than earlier and later
on went to become minister of war for France.
In epilogue
fast forwards 7 years after reinstatement of Dreyfus. Dreyfus comes to visit Picquart
and complains about his rank and requests a promotion. Picquart replies
negatively and adds that politically at this moment it would be impossible to
be done. Picquart says that he wouldn’t have to attend such a high position
without him. But Dreyfus replies “No my General, you attend it because you did
your duty”.
Overall this
contemporary mystery thriller novel establishes on a scandalous testimonial of
government and military atrocities. Dreyfus and Piquart won their individual
cases in the military court in the end but lost precious years and faced mental
and physical tortures. Justice always triumphs but it takes a lot of time and
sacrifices. This whole story is a true depiction of it.